Georgia
E-Voting: Illegal and Unconstitutional
On July 13, 2006 a group of
Georgia
citizens, organized by VoterGa.org, filed suit on behalf of
all nine million current and future
Georgia
voters contending that our current electronic voting method is
illegal and unconstitutional according to state law. The
charges may seem overstated to an uninformed observer but this
overview of the 7 legal counts reveals the unreported detail:
Machine Accuracy �
Georgia
law requires that electronic voting machines ��record
correctly and accurately every vote cast�� at the
time they are used. No procedure was ever implemented to
ensure that the machines record the votes accurately on
election night when they are used.
Recount Ability � State
law provides conditions when candidates are entitled to a
recount of votes. Georgia E-Voting made recounts impossible
because it removed all direct physical evidence of voter
intent from our elections. Voter verified ballots were
replaced by voter inaccessible electronic records. Only
reprint previous unverifiable results are now possible.
Ballot Requirement � The
Georgia Constitution requires all elections to be conducted by
ballot. When E-Voting was implemented in 2002,
Georgia
law was modified to state that elections �shall be
conducted by ballot except when voting machines are used��
State law cannot override a Constitutional requirement.
Elections must be conducted by ballot, not by electronic
record.
People Participation - The
Georgia Constitution defines our �method
of voting� as �elections
by the people�. Currently, the people cannot see the
selections on their own ballots, cannot confirm that their
ballots were cast and cannot participate in counting the votes
to determine election results. All critical functions of �elections
by the people� were unconstitutionally removed from the
people.
Equal Protection � The
Constitution also states: �No person shall be denied the
equal protection of the laws.�
Georgia
absentee voters cast votes on standard ballots that can be
verified, audited and recounted. Georgia Election Day voters
do not have those same privileges and are denied equal
protection of the laws stated above.
The lawsuit also claims the
audit trail pilot project is unconstitutional and illegal as
follows:
Ballot Secrecy � The
Constitution requires that elections �must
be conducted by secret ballot� so that no one can
identify candidates that the voter chose. The newer Diebold
pilot project machines roll election results sequentially into
a sealed canister. This technique can allow a poll worker or
observer who accesses the results to determine precisely what
candidates each voter selected.
Machine Accuracy � The
newer Diebold pilot machines also cannot meet time of use
accuracy requirements because they do not produce individually
separated ballots that can be quickly counted and audited once
the polls close. The new pilot project law even allows for
machine results to be audited AFTER the election results are
certified.
The basic relief that the
lawsuit will seek could have been implemented in 2002
including:
- Statewide external audit
trails for all electronic voting machines;
- A public audit of at least
one randomly selected race at the precinct on election
night;
- An automatic race recount if
similar audit count discrepancies are found across
precincts.
Instead, citizens like those in
VoterGa who have already spent thousands of hours and dollars
on this issue now must file suit to restore voting that can be
verified, audited and recounted. As you can see, all seven
counts of the suit are very strong. We need to win only
one of the first five counts to win the case against current
E-voting and just one of the last two counts to win
against the pilot project. Georgia needs your immediate help
so that we can take appropriate legal action to restore voting
that can be verified, audited and recounted.
Freedom is not free. Please click the Donation
button to contribute or mail your contribution to:
Voter GA P.O.
Box 808 Decatur, Ga. 30031
We are a volunteer organization
so all money that you give will directly offset the
legal expenses of preparing, filing and arguing this suit
to preserve the principles of democracy in Georgia. See
the Contribute page for infomration about special gifts for
donors. Thank you.